How Hiring Managers Review Resumes: Tips for Candidates to Stand Out

Your resume is your first chance to impress potential employers, making it crucial to showcase your qualifications effectively. A well-crafted resume reflects your dedication, expertise, and commitment to your field. Presenting your skills and achievements strategically can make all the difference.

Last update:
01/01/2024
How Hiring Managers Review Resumes: Tips for Candidates to Stand Out

Write your resume in 15 minutes

Our free collection of expertly designed resume templates will help you stand out from the crowd and get one step closer to your dream job.

Create your resume
Table of contents
Table of content
Create my resume with AI

Write your resume in 15 minutes

Our free collection of expertly designed resume templates will help you stand out from the crowd and get one step closer to your dream job.

Create my resume

This guide offers tips to create a professional, impactful resume that helps you stand out in a competitive job market. Learn how to highlight your strengths, tailor your content, and capture the attention of hiring managers.

Key Points Covered in This Guide:

  1. Steps Hiring Managers Follow During Resume Review
  2. Essential Elements of a Standout Resume
  3. Common Resume Mistakes to Avoid
  4. Optimize Resumes for ATS and Human Review
  5. Tips to Prepare for Interviews Based on Your Resume

Steps for Hiring Managers to Review Resumes


Man showing his workmates documents

Step 1: Initial Screening

The first step is often handled by ATS software. These systems filter out resumes that do not pass to include relevant keywords or the gaps where candidates fail to meet baseline qualifications.

Tips for Passing the ATS Screening:

  • Include keywords from the job posting naturally throughout your resume.
  • Avoid overly complex designs, graphics, or tables that ATS systems may not recognize.
  • Use clear and conventional section titles such as "Work Experience," "Skills," and "Education" to enhance ATS compatibility.

Step 2: Detailed Review by Hiring Managers

Once a resume passes the ATS, hiring managers carefully examine cover letter and its content. They look for:

  • Clear Career Progression: Does the resume show growth and increasing responsibility over time?
  • Relevant Experience: Are the candidate’s past roles aligned with the job’s requirements?
  • Metrics of Success: Quantifiable achievements such as "Increased team efficiency by 20%" stand out more than vague claims.

Step 3: Shortlisting Candidates

Resumes that demonstrate strong technical and soft skills, combined with relevant achievements, are shortlisted. Hiring managers may also consider certifications, leadership experience, and cultural fit.

Essential Elements of a Standout Resume


1. Professional Layout and Formatting

A clean and well-organized resume is easy to read and makes a strong impression. Use bullet points, consistent fonts, and a simple design.

Example Layout:

  • Professional Summary: A brief overview of your career achievements and goals.
  • Work Experience: Use reverse-chronological order to highlight your most recent and relevant roles.
  • Skills and Certifications: List technical and industry-specific skills alongside certifications like "Certified Scrum Master" or "CFA Level I."
  • Education: Include degrees, relevant coursework, and any honors.
Serious workers discussing document in office lobby

2. Action-Oriented Language

Use strong, action-oriented verbs to describe your own application process, organization, achievements and responsibilities. Words like "initiated," "optimized," "led," and "implemented" convey a proactive and results-driven approach to application process.

Example:
Instead of “Helped with team projects and business side,” write “Led a team of 5 to complete training for a product launch in short time, resulting in a 15% increase in sales.”

📌 For more powerful alternatives to commonly overused words like "helped," explore this guide on resume synonyms.

3. Quantifiable Achievements

Numbers and statistics demonstrate your impact more effectively than general statements. Hiring managers appreciate specific business outcomes, such as:

  • "Improved operational efficiency by 25% through process redesign."
  • "Generated $500,000 in new business revenue by implementing targeted marketing campaigns."

4. Tailored Content

Customize your resume for each job application. Align your skills, experiences, and achievements with the job description.

For example:

Common Resume Mistakes to Avoid


  1. Overloading with Irrelevant Information: Focus on roles, skills, and achievements that are relevant to the job you’re applying for.
  2. Using a Generic Resume: Avoid sending the same resume to multiple jobs without tailoring it to specific roles.
  3. Typos and Grammar Errors: Even a minor mistake can leave a poor impression. Proofread carefully or use tools like Grammarly to check for errors.
  4. Exaggerated Claims: Always be truthful about your qualifications and achievements.

Optimizing Your Resume for ATS and Human Review


Cheerful Businesswoman Holding Documents Sitting At Laptop In Modern Office

1. Incorporate Keywords Naturally

Identify the key employment history and industry terms in the job and position description and include them in your next resume too, but make sure they fit naturally into your content.

2. Use a Simple and Standard Format

Avoid complex screen graphics or unusual fonts. ATS systems and hiring managers prefer straightforward screen layouts.

3. Include a Professional Summary

A professional summary at the top of your resume can grab attention quickly. For example: “Dynamic financial analyst with 5+ years of experience in risk assessment and portfolio management consulting. Proven ability to deliver $1M cost savings through strategic investment analysis.”

📌 For a quick and professional resume, try the Resume builder to create an ATS-friendly layout.

Preparing for Interviews Based on Your Resume


Your resume serves as the foundation for most interview questions. Hiring managers will often reference specific roles, jobs, achievements, or skills mentioned in your resume during the interview.

1. Anticipate Common Questions

Be prepared to elaborate on your experience. Questions may include:

  • "Can you explain how you achieved [specific result] in your previous role?"
  • "What challenges did you face while leading [specific project]?"

2. Practice Behavioral and Situational Questions

Behavioral questions focus on past experiences, while situational questions test your problem-solving abilities in depth now. Learn more about situational interview questions in depth to be ready for these. Prepare for behavioral interview questions to highlight your competencies.

Two businesspeople examining documents in restaurant

3. Ask Thoughtful Questions During the Interview

Show your interest in the role and company by asking insightful questions. For instance:

Final Thoughts


A well-crafted resume is your gateway to a successful job application. By understanding how hiring managers review qualified candidates and applicants, reviewing others' resumes and tailoring yours to align your skill set with their priorities, you can significantly increase your chances of standing out.

Remember to:

  • Use a professional format.
  • Highlight quantifiable achievements.
  • Customize your resume for each job application.
  • Proofread to avoid errors.

Once your resume secures an interview, preparation is key. Research the job history and company, practice your answers, and be ready to discuss and present your experiences confidently. A strong resume combined with a polished interview performance will set you apart as a recruiter as a top candidate with a job history.

Create your resume with the best templates

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do I make my resume ATS-friendly?

Use standard headings, include relevant keywords naturally, and avoid complex designs or graphics. Keep formatting simple to ensure the ATS can read and parse your information accurately.

What achievements should I include?

Focus on quantifiable results, such as metrics, percentages, or dollar figures. For example, “Increased sales by 20% through targeted marketing campaigns.”

How often should I customize my resume?

Customize your resume for each job application by aligning your skills and experience with the job description. Tailoring ensures relevance and increases your chances of passing both ATS and manual reviews.

Create your resume in 15 minutes

Our free collection of expertly designed cover letter templates will help you stand out from the crowd and get one step closer to your dream job.

Create my resume